Originally Sent: 2/5/2015
February 5, 2015
Join 20,000 others...
The HSLDA Curriculum Market is buzzing with activity! Save money on new and used homeschooling materials, or sell your extras.
Color Mapping Paragraphs and Essays
We enjoy entering your homes each month via the high school newsletter. Although it is definitely a one-sided conversation with us doing all of the “talking,” we try our best to anticipate your questions and provide you with useful information relating to some aspect of high school that may have left you stumped or searching for advice.
Parents often ask us about the difference between middle school and high school courses. The primary difference is the academic papers students must learn to write for various subjects. Composition skills learned in English should spill over into science and history. During high school, the study of English moves away from grammar exercises to reading and understanding great literature and developing higher level composition skills. For more information on the four elements of a high school English course, read this archived newsletter.
Many parents feel intimidated by the prospect of teaching academic writing, and they have legitimate questions about the differences between creative writing, paragraphs, and essays. Often students who enjoy creative writing bring the narrative style to their academic compositions. However, essays are not stories, and academic writing has a recognizable format students must learn and practice. Let’s address the nuts and bolts of paragraph and essay organization with the Color Mapping (CM) method, developed during Carol’s many years of teaching high school writing to homeschooled students.
Color Mapping Paragraphs
The CM method helps students understand where certain information belongs within a paragraph, and organization builds on the analogy of climbing a mountain. The topic sentence is the signpost pointing a hiker to the trailhead. The interesting facts are the hike up the mountainside. The insight is the breathtaking view from the top.
Every good academic paragraph begins with a topic sentence written in the student’s own words and showcases the main idea under discussion. With CM, students either write the topic sentence in blue or underline it because this visually shows its position and prominence. Primarily, the topic sentence points the reader to the paragraph’s insight without revealing the full view, and it addresses why a climber should hike this mountain. Many students find this opening sentence easier to write once they have determined the rest of the paragraph. Questions and quotations are unsuitable options for topic sentences.
Just as mountain climbs consist mostly of hiking the trail, most of the academic paragraph consists of interesting facts. With CM, students either write these sentences in red font or underline them because this visually shows the position and quantity of factual information within the paragraph. Although science and history facts seem straightforward to most students, misunderstanding the nature of literary facts causes some confusion. Literary facts come directly from the novel, play, poem, or short story, and they consist of conflicts, decisions, mistakes, consequences, characterizations, quotations, and symbolism found within the literature. If a student can turn to an actual page in a novel where something happened, then this is a literary fact. For more detail about helping students discern literary facts, review this newsletter. Students may also use historical details about the author’s life and generation.
All paragraphs benefit from well-developed information. To the reader, one fact seems anecdotal—curious but not persuasive. Although two facts are better, coincidence is not the best foundation for advancing an argument. Three interesting facts establish a pattern worthy of consideration. To organize information, many students revert to storytelling; however, the narrative style does not belong in academic paragraphs because essays respectfully argue points—not entertain readers. To develop structure, other writers resort to a question-and-answer format. Although this is an acceptable style for lower-level compositions, high school students must develop a mature writing style. Any questions should be rhetorical in nature because the answer should be obvious and require no explanation. Rhetorical questions make the writer appear reasonable and less adamant. The CM method recommends that insight—the glorious view at the end of the hike—govern how students organize interesting facts.
Just as people hike a mountain in order to enjoy the view, a paragraph should have the same goal and not disappoint the reader. In our information-saturated society, the ability to understand the meaning behind facts sets discerning leaders apart from unquestioning followers. insight is not only the most challenging part of any paragraph but also the most important feature. Homeschool parents should strive to develop their teens’ higher level thinking skills by teaching students how to see the bigger picture. Strengthen these skills by discussing concepts, correlations, and consequences with your teens regularly. Most students must verbalize significant ideas with adults to formulate insights before teens can compose them alone.
Color Mapping Outlines
A useful outlining technique benefits all writers, but most students have not learned a practical method. Others consider a paragraph too short to require an outline. The CM method helps students examine interesting facts for consistency, and it enables them to rearrange the facts in logical manner. Following the same color coding conventions detailed for topic sentences, interesting facts, and insights, students begin by jotting down information but not in sentence form. Instead, instruct your students to write disjointed lists of phrases, clauses, and vocabulary words. (Employ parentheses to define important vocabulary.) When students write sentences on outlines, this prevents them from detecting unbalanced or mismatched facts, and writers certainly resist sentence modifications. Conversely, students likely won’t have qualms about moving, modifying, or deleting phrases/clauses because the hard work of sentence building has not yet occurred.
As most students find facts to be the easiest part of the writing process, students came to Carol’s class with the three interesting facts filled in with idea-rich phrases and clauses. Carol met individually with each student to discuss an appropriate insight, which each student wrote down. At this juncture, most students can now clearly see how facts should be reordered, revised, or restructured to substantiate the insight. Lastly, students choose three words that they will use to construct a signpost for the trailhead—the topic sentence. Now students have a practical outline full of significant phrases and clauses in logical progression. Students are well equipped at this stage to write an academic paragraph.
Color Mapping Essays
The CM method helps students understand how essay sections fit together. By writing three or more CM paragraphs on different aspects of a novel, play, poem or short story, parents can teach students how to generate their first CM essay. The standard essay format begins with an introductory paragraph, followed by three or more body paragraphs, and culminates with a concluding paragraph.
Color Mapping Introductory Paragraph
Although students have great latitude in beginning a composition, academic essays have only one introductory paragraph, and the last sentence is the thesis. Students should follow these steps to build an introductory paragraph:
Color Mapping Body Paragraphs
Each body paragraph follows the CM paragraph previously described, but students should order the body paragraphs from least important to most profound insight because significance plays a role in organization. To understand this principle, consider the following court room analogy. At the beginning of a trial, the judge states the charge (opening and background), and the defendant pleads guilty or not guilty (thesis). Once the prosecution has presented its case, the defense attorney (writer) concentrates on crucial points raised by the prosecution: motive, means, and opportunity (main points). The attorney addresses each main point in logical order (body paragraphs), and he calls witnesses to testify (interesting facts). The lawyer seeks to show that the defendant had nothing to gain by the crime, never touched the weapon, and was out of town when the crime occurred (insight), and he builds from least to most significant point.
Color Mapping Concluding Paragraph
The concluding paragraph has three goals, and students have flexibility in the format. The CM method includes the thesis and insights in this paragraph, but writers must avoid any interesting facts or new information. Instead, students summarize the concepts and ideas already presented—not verbatim but with different wording. Students should keep these goals in mind for the concluding paragraph:
This last paragraph showcases the student’s best writing. Often the essay’s title mirrors a phrase from this closing paragraph.
Once students feel confident with the paragraph, encourage them to write paragraphs for science and history classes. As essay skills develop, students should write essays in other subjects. Wherever your teen is in the writing process, begin with organization skills for paragraphs and essays. By understanding how to nurture writing skills, you can improve upon any publisher’s curriculum, and this will give you confidence to teach your teen composition skills
Join us next month as we discuss the important role that teachers play in developing independent learners.
Encouraging you in your teen’s writing endeavors,
Carol Becker and Diane Kummer
"Homeschooling Thru Highschool" is a newsletter of the Home School Legal Defense Association. All rights reserved. For more information on Homeschooling Thru Highschool or the Home School Legal Defense Association please contact us at:
HSLDA • P.O. Box 3000 • Purcellville, Virginia 20134-9000
Subscription Information: You subscribed to the "Homeschooling Thru Highschool" email as:
POSTMASTERS: This message is being sent to the most recent address we have for our subscribers. If this is an invalid email address or you have other problems, please reply to email@example.com.
DISCLAIMER: This is considered a private and confidential message from HSLDA to its bonafide HSLDA E-lert Service subscribers. HSLDA cannot attest to the authenticity of copies posted, forwarded, or sent by any party other than HSLDA.
ADVERTISING WITH US: The appearance of advertisements in the Homeschooling thru High School newsletter does not imply recommendation or endorsement by Home School Legal Defense Association, and the opinions expressed by advertisers do not necessarily reflect the views of HSLDA. Use of any information, product, or service herein advertised is voluntary, and reliance upon it should only be undertaken after independent review. Caveat emptor—let the buyer beware.
NOTE: Please do not reply or otherwise use this email address; firstname.lastname@example.org is for broadcast purposes only and is not intended to receive incoming messages. We cannot reply to any email sent to this address. If you have comments or questions, please send email to email@example.com or call HSLDA at 540-338-5600. HSLDA members can also email staff directly through the Members website at http://members.hslda.org/contact.asp. Thank you for your cooperation.© 2018 HSLDA. All rights reserved.