Share this page:

July 15, 2013

Sixth Circuit Denies Romeike Rehearing,
HSLDA Promises to go to Supreme Court


Uwe and Hannelore Romeike fled from Germany to the United States after their family was vigorously prosecuted (fines, forcible removal of their children, threats of jail and more) for homeschooling. Initially, the Romeikes were granted political asylum, but the U.S. government appealed that decision to the Board of Immigration Appeals. That Board sided with the government. HSLDA then appealed to the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals—which denied asylum. HSLDA now plans to petition the U.S. Supreme Court.

The U.S. Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals denied the Home School Legal Defense Association’s (HSLDA) request for rehearing of the Romeike case last Friday after seemingly showing interest in the case. HSLDA will now submit a petition for review by the Supreme Court of the United States to continue the fight for the Romeike family’s asylum.

HSLDA submitted a petition for rehearing en banc on May 28, and the Sixth Circuit asked the Department of Justice to respond on June 12. The petition was then denied on the grounds that the points raised had already been considered during the original hearing.

Fight for Freedom

“This is not over yet,” said Michael Farris, founder and chairman of HSLDA. “We are taking this case to the Supreme Court because we firmly believe that this family deserves the freedom that this country was founded on. Despite Friday’s order, the Sixth Circuit’s opinion contains two clear errors: First, they wholly ignored Germany’s proclamation that a central reason for banning homeschooling is to suppress religious minorities. Second, the Sixth Circuit erred when it failed to address the claim that parental rights are so fundamental that no government can deny parents the right to choose an alternative to the public schools.”

The Romeike family faces thousands of dollars in fines and possible jail time if they return to Germany. HSLDA contends that this is grounds for a well-founded fear of persecution that would grant them asylum under U.S. law. The Justice Department, however, claims that the Romeikes are being punished under a generally applicable law, and the Sixth Circuit agreed.

Evidence Ignored

“The German High Court is on record for saying that religious homeschoolers should be targeted and severely punished, yet our Justice Department sees nothing wrong with that,” Farris said. “The Attorney General and Sixth Circuit are ignoring critical evidence and are trying to send back this family who is trying to stay in our country legally. We are hopeful that the Supreme Court will go the other way and see what the original immigration judge saw: that this family and other religious homeschoolers in Germany are being persecuted for what they believe is the right way to raise their children.”

HSLDA has until October 11, 2013, to petition to the Supreme Court, and at the time of this writing, has not yet set a date to submit their brief.

• • •

You Can Help

To make a tax-deductible gift to the Homeschool Freedom Fund, which will fund litigation and educating the public about homeschooling, click here. If you are not an HSLDA member, join now! For more information about opportunities to support the work of HSLDA see the FAQ here.